By Tabitha Evans Moore | EDITOR & PUBLISHER
CHATTANOOGA, Tenn. — A new emergency motion filed Monday in Eastern District Federal Court asks a judge to expedite a hearing on whether the receivership overseeing Uncle Nearest, Inc. should continue, while also supporting the continued sealing of sensitive filings in the case. The motion was filed by Grant Sidney Inc. and founders Fawn Weaver and Keith Weaver, who are seeking reconsideration of earlier court orders that placed the company under receivership.
In the filing, the movants argue that circumstances have materially changed since the receiver was appointed and that the extraordinary relief of a receivership should be reassessed on a fully developed evidentiary record. They request an expedited, multi-day hearing so the court can hear testimony regarding enterprise value, brand performance, lending decisions, and governance. Alternatively, if a prompt hearing cannot be scheduled, the motion asks the court to temporarily limit the receiver’s role to monitoring and asset preservation while restoring day-to-day operational control to the company’s board and leadership.
The motion also supports keeping certain filings under seal, echoing arguments previously raised by the receiver and Farm Credit Mid-America, PCA. According to the filing, public disclosure of sensitive financial information, proprietary data, distributor relationships, and potential litigation could further erode brand value and harm efforts to stabilize the company. The movants cite comparable proceedings in the spirits industry where key filings were handled under seal to protect enterprise value during restructuring or insolvency proceedings.
Substantively, the 18-page filing contends that the receivership itself has contributed to a sharp decline in sales and enterprise value. The motion references retail scan data showing that Uncle Nearest outperformed the broader American whiskey market prior to the appointment of the receiver, but began underperforming shortly afterward. The movants assert that uncertainty surrounding governance and ownership, coupled with operational decisions made during the receivership, negatively impacted distribution and retail availability during critical sales periods.
The court has not yet ruled on the request for an expedited hearing or the alternative relief proposed. The emergency motion comes as multiple disputes related to the receivership and underlying lending relationship remain pending before the court.
Plain English: What’s this filing about?
The founders of Uncle Nearest, Inc. are asking the federal judge to take a fresh look at whether the company should still be under court-appointed receivership. They argue that the receivership was put in place quickly, based on limited information, and that what has happened since then — including a steep drop in sales — shows the situation may now be doing more harm than good. After all, the point of Farm Credit’s lawsuit is to recover over $100 million dollars in loans that originated in 2022, and declining sales are not helpful to that end.
They are not asking the court to resolve the entire case right now. Instead, they want an expedited evidentiary hearing — essentially a mini-trial — where witnesses can testify and data can be examined before deciding whether the receivership should continue, be scaled back, or end altogether. They argue that without quick court intervention, uncertainty around leadership and control could further damage the brand and reduce its value.
The filing also supports keeping certain documents under seal. The founders agree with the receiver and lender that publicly releasing sensitive financial information, distribution data, or potential litigation details could undermine ongoing efforts to stabilize the company, refinance debt, or explore strategic options. All parties would still have access to the sealed materials; the restriction would apply only to public disclosure.
As a fallback, if the judge cannot schedule a prompt hearing, the founders ask for a temporary compromise: limit the receiver’s role to monitoring finances and preserving assets, while returning day-to-day business decisions to the company’s board and leadership until the court makes a final decision.
What this does not mean
This filing does not mean the receivership has ended, been reversed, or been found improper. The receiver remains in place unless and until the court orders otherwise. The motion simply asks the judge to reconsider earlier decisions based on new developments and a more complete factual record.
The motion also does not resolve the underlying lawsuits or determine liability. No findings of wrongdoing are made or undone by this filing, and no damages are awarded. The court is being asked only to decide how control and oversight of the company should function while those broader legal questions continue to move through the courts.
What happen next
The judge will first decide whether to grant an expedited hearing on the motion to reconsider the receivership. That decision could come quickly, given that the filing is labeled an emergency motion and requests court time within weeks, not months.
If the court agrees to a hearing, it would allow testimony from company leadership, financial experts, and potentially representatives of Farm Credit Mid-America, PCA, creating a fuller record than what existed when the receiver was originally appointed. After that hearing, the judge could keep the receivership in place, modify its scope, or terminate it altogether. •
About The Lynchburg Times: We’re independent, reader-supported, and proudly homegrown. We hold the history, relationships, and journalistic craft to deliver professional reporting from one of America’s tiniest and most famous towns. Because of that, there are some stories you’ll only read in The Lynchburg Times. Every dollar of reader support stays right here in Moore County, funding local writers, photographers, and storytellers. When you support The Lynchburg Times, you’re not just backing a local newsroom — you’re preserving the art of storytelling in the South. [Join us here.]