By Tabitha Evans Moore | EDITOR & PUBLISHER
COBB HOLLOW COMMUNITY — In a world full of shortcuts and mass-produced everything, there’s something grounding about walking into a room where the old ways still matter. In the Cobb Hollow community of Moore County, inside a converted carport attached to a family home she never meant to buy, Cyndy Carroll stands over a line of Mason jars and a pot of melting organic soy wax. Charms wait in tiny bowls. Burlap bags are stacked in neat piles. Every piece of her process is intentional, and none of it is fast.
Most people, she’ll tell you, think a candle is simple. Light the wick, enjoy the scent, toss the jar. Her process suggests otherwise.
Crafted, Not Produced
Carroll grew up here – Moore County schools, Bennett Road roots, a childhood shaped by sewing lessons, crafts, and the kind of generational creativity Southern families pass down without naming it. After her mother became ill, she stepped away from work to help her father care for her. When her mother passed, she found herself asking the same question many caregivers ask when the dust settles: What now?
What emerged wasn’t so much a business plan but a purpose. She wanted something she could make with her hands, something that honored her aesthetic, something clean and safe enough for any home. The Lynchburg Candle Company began with that impulse – and the urge to do it right, or not at all.
“There’s like 10 million people out there selling candles, but I wanted mine to stand out in a certain way,” she says. “I wanted candles that looked and smelled great but didn’t have any carcinogens in them, didn’t cause cancer.”
{EDITOR’S NOTE: Locally-owned, small businesses are the lifeblood of small, rural towns. Our small business profiles are sponsored by our community partners at First Community Bank. Please support the local businesses that support your community newspaper.}
The Science Behind a Simple Flame
What sets Carroll apart is what she refuses to skip. Candle testing, she says, is where most makers cut corners.
Every time she introduces a new fragrance – even if it’s going into the same size jar with the same cotton wick – she starts testing from scratch. Fragrance load affects burn rate. The wrong combination causes wicks to “knock off,” sputter out, or burn too hot. Each candle must burn evenly and all the way down without the glass overheating.
That’s why she can’t simply refill a jar for a customer, even if they’ve saved every container they’ve ever bought from her.
“I don’t know how they burned it the first time,” she explains. “If they let it burn empty too long, the glass can degrade. If I pour a new candle into that jar and it cracks, that’s a liability.”
It’s also why she refuses paraffin. Petroleum-based wax leaves soot – sometimes enough to stain a wall. She’s seen the shadows left behind when homeowners move their framed photos and discover a clean rectangle in an otherwise smoky room.
Her solution? A higher standard.
Cotton wicks. 100 percent soy wax grown in the United States. Jars made in Arkansas. Scents chosen not just for strength, but for memory, place, and purity.
Aesthetic With Integrity
The first thing many people notice about Carroll’s candles aren’t the scents at all – it’s the presentation. The Mason jars. The small silver charms. The burlap bags that make every candle feel like a gift.
“I wanted it to be country,” she says, “but not too country. I didn’t want it to look like a $5 handmade candle.”
Her aesthetic is quiet but intentional: elevated simplicity with a distinctly local heartbeat. The charms have become collectibles; customers build bracelets with them. The bags become keepsakes long after the flame burns down.
Her Apple Harvest candle, one of her most popular, was created in memory of her mother. The special pillow-ticking bag that accompanies it nods to her mother’s restaurant in the 1990s, where servers wore aprons made from the same, blue-striped fabric. A portion of each sale goes to Alzheimer’s research.
She also creates other scents with names like Wild Rose, Sweet Southern Grace, Snickerdoodle, White Tea, Toasted Pumpkin, Oak Moss & Amber as well as Christmas in Lynchburg, which is a big seller this time of year. Most scents come in multiple sizes and are also available as soy wax melts.
She also creates small glass bottles filled with wooden matches made with a handy strike on the cap. To see her full line, visit her website.
Small on Purpose
Plenty of people have tried to convince Carroll to scale – to open more wholesale accounts, ship nationwide, expand production. She always shakes her head.
“I might could,” she says, “but then I wouldn’t get to do the things that are special to me. The donating. The small-town thing. I’m good where I’m at.”
She gives away wherever she sees a need. Candles for charity auctions. Tea lights and match bottles for women’s retreats across the Southeast. Fire starters made from recaptured soy because she refuses to waste anything she’s poured.
Vendor events are always a gamble. Sometimes she sells out. Sometimes she takes a few items back home with her. Soy has a shelf life, so sometimes unsold items becomes something else like fire starters – all repurposed by hand.
But she seems unfazed by the unpredictability. That, too, is part of the craft.
Integrity in a Shortcut World
Candle making, in Carroll’s hands, is less a hobby and more a discipline – one built on patience, testing, clean materials, and the belief that small-scale work can still matter. At a time when most people want fast, cheap, and convenient, she continues to choose slow, careful, and personal.
The Lynchburg Candle Company isn’t the biggest or the flashiest. It isn’t meant to be.
It’s a reminder that the old way – the honest way – is still alive in Moore County. Sometimes the brightest light comes from keeping things small, keeping them clean, and keeping them human.
If you’d like to purchase a Lynchburg Candle Co. creation, they are sold in Lynchburg at the Tennessee Whiskey Trailhead Gift Shop or in Pulaski at the Yellow Deli. She also plans to sell at a vendor booth during Lynchburg’s annual Christmas in Lynchburg on December 6.
To learn more about The Lynchburg Candle Co. reach out to Carroll at her Facebook page or website.•
About The Lynchburg Times: We’re independent, reader-supported, and proudly homegrown. We hold the history, relationships, and journalistic craft to deliver professional reporting from one of America’s tiniest and most famous towns. Because of that, there are some stories you’ll only read in The Lynchburg Times. Every dollar of reader support stays right here in Moore County, funding local writers, photographers, and storytellers. When you support The Lynchburg Times, you’re not just backing a newspaper — you’re preserving the art of storytelling in the South. [Join us here.]